Skip to main content

Court of Appeal Pirates Case Decision...

It is certainly interesting to read the reactions of Kenyans to the High Court Decision by Justice Ibrahim in November, 2010 stating that Kenya had no Criminal Jurisdiction to try Suspected Pirates arrested in the Indian Ocean under Kenyan law, and that the persons ought to be handed over to the UNHCR to be treated as refugees. 

One of the comments in the online edition of the 18th October, 2012 Daily Nation reads in part: 
"Wonder how a thief who gets into my boma cannot face the full wrath of my blunt panga..." 

Well that 'blunt' part was a little too bluntly put!... and since we are a country that is governed by the rule of law and believe in due process, we opt for the decision today of the Court of Appeal which overturned this ruling. Appellate Judges Maraga, Onyango, Vishram, Okwengu and Koome held that that Kenyan courts had jurisdiction to hear and make a determination on piracy cases that have over the years become a 'thorn in the flesh' of Kenya's and East Africa's economic development. 

Am certainly looking forward to reading the allowed Appeal that quashed the decision of the now Supreme Court Judge Ibrahim. 

The amount of economic strain that this decision places on our  already overwhelmed legal system is certainly immense considering the levels of insecurity that have been witnessed along the East African and larger Horn-of Africa coast line. Whether or not the international community will and should invest in this process - as it is a stakeholder and a direct beneficiary of a pirate -free coast line is a discussion for another day.

Kenya has international obligations as provided for in the Constitution as well as under International Law. All state organs are bound by any international instruments that Kenya enters into and the Judiciary is no exception. Let us see how the cases progress at the lower courts and whether there will be enough to sustain convictions.

It would also be interesting to follow debates and discussions on how far our obligations under international law stretch especially when dealing with issues that have economic implication, and whether the courts will at some point have to weigh in on the discussions and make decisions striking a balance between pressing national obligations (like food security, national security, protection of socio-economic rights) and these international obligations. 

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Supreme Court Presidential Petition Number 4 of 2017 (Njonjo Mue & Another Vs. Chairperson IEBC & 3 Others

Post backdated to 20th November, 2017:  About 2 weeks ago, i was called up by a seniour lawyer who asked me to join him for an early morning meeting. It is at that meeting that i was invited to be part of the legal team preparing a petition challenging the election of Hon. Uhuru Kenyatta - Supreme Court Presidential Petition 4 of 2017.  To have been found worthy of inclusion for this assignment is humbling, any lawyer (young or old) would be excited at such an opportunity. An opportunity to practice law at Kenya’s  apex court, in one of the most contentious issue the Supreme Court has original jurisdiction over! One hell of an emotive issue too!  I accepted and was immediately tasked with the preparation of the Petition’s principal affidavit. The next 7 days were going to be a roller coaster. From sleepless nights and nights with little sleep, to change of location nearly 4 times for fear of police raids, late night meetings with lawyers i never dream...
3 comments
Read more

THE “HOUSE OF TERROR” – Reflections….

The "House of Terror" - Budapest, 1062 Andrassy ut 60 So today I finally got to visit the ‘House of Terror’ one of those places you certainly ought to visit if you ever pass by Budapest, Hungary! It is described as a museum that commemorates the victims of terror as well as a reminder of the dreadful acts of terror carried out by ‘victimizers’. The building, and the museum inside are a vivid, impressive recreation of different periods of Hungarian history that the country has tried to move on from albeit painfully. The Different sections of the Museum that begins with a hallway full of victims, then instruments of torture, actual cells, gallows and a morgue, witness accounts displayed on screens and pictures that tell a thousand words all bear testimony to the atrocities witnessed and meted. The building housed the Hungarian Nazis in the early 1940’s and later a residence of the AVO and subsequently the AVH who are known to have participated in the worst forms of crimes agai...
3 comments
Read more

Museveni defending Gaddafi.....How?!?!!?!?!

                                                  Like many Africans I have reservations with the west prescribing ‘sound solutions’ for African problems, and would therefore in many ways align myself with African scholars who have had enough of meddling by the west in the guise of offering much needed, sensible, practical solutions and elucidations about how to successfully steer countries from histories of autocracy, dictatorship and poor governance to the path of democracy. Indeed, nothing would make me more proud than successful home-grown solutions for the seemingly endless challenges faced by many African countries. As a matter of fact I have no doubt of Africa ’s capability to resolve to address its own challenges as individual states...
2 comments
Read more